West Coast Eagles Wiki
West Coast v Melbourne
Round 9, 2019
Ryan flies for a spectacular mark. Photo: aflphotos.com.au
Fri, 17 May 2019 (6.10pm WST)
Won by 16
WCE 13.7.85 - 9.15.69 MEL
3 E.Yeo (WCE)
2 M.Gawn (WCE)
1 D.Sheed (WCE)

West Coast came from behind to record an important victory over Melbourne, putting through six goals in the final term to thwart the Demons' efforts to take revenge for their preliminary final exist the previous year. Melbourne controlled the midfield for the first three quarters thanks to ruckman Max Gawn's dominance, but squandered chances and left the door open for the Eagles' fourth-quarter revival. Elliot Yeo was immense with 26 possessions (18 contested) and a career-high 16 tackles, and Josh Kennedy kicked four goals.


1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
West Coast 3.2.20 5.4.34 7.6.48 13.7.85
Melbourne 3.4.22 5.8.38 8.12.60 9.15.69

Goals: Kennedy 4, Cripps, Rioli, Shuey 2, Darling, Ryan, Sheed

Best: Yeo, Hurn, Kennedy, Sheed, Shuey, Gaff

Injuries: Venables (concussion), Hickey (ankle)

Reports: Jetta for rough conduct against T.Smith, Yeo for misconduct against J.Harmes

Milestones: Ryan Mark of the Year, Venables final appearance

Named sides[]

West Coast Melbourne
B: 25.Hurn 31.Schofield 5.Sheppard B: 34.Hore 17.Frost 29.Hunt
HB: 14.Duggan 20.McGovern 23.Jetta HB: 2.Jones 28.O.McDonald 3.Salem
C: 8.Redden 13.Shuey 4.Sheed C: 10.Brayshaw 7.Viney 15.Stretch
HF: 18.Venables 27.Darling 44.Rioli HF: 41.Lockhart 25.T.McDonald 30.Neal-Bullen
F: 1.Ryan 17.Kennedy 15.Cripps F: 36.Garlett 5.Petracca 38.T.Smith
R: 19.Vardy 6.Yeo 3.Gaff R: 11.Gawn 4.Harmes 13.Oliver
I: 21.Petruccelle 28.Cole 34.Hutchings I: 35.Petty 31.Fritsch 42.J.Wagner
12.O.Allen 33.Baker
E: 45.Smith 16.Hickey 30.Nelson E: 40.C.Wagner 37.Chandler 32.Sparrow
2.Waterman 21.Preuss

In: Rioli

Out: Waterman

Late change: Hickey for Schofield (soreness)

Quarter by quarter[]

West Coast replaced Schofield with Hickey before the bounce, with the defender failing to recover from a heavy clash the previous week. The change forced Allen into defence, with Hickey and Vardy double-teaming All-Australian ruckman Max Gawn. The match was played in fine but chilly conditions.

Club Champion votes[]


Hurn 15 Cole 6
McGovern 15 Cripps 6
Ryan 15 Duggan 6
Yeo 15 Petruccelle 6
Shuey 13 Rioli 5
Kennedy 11 Hickey 4
Sheed 11 Hutchings 4
Gaff 8 Redden 4
Sheppard 8 Darling 2
Jetta 7 Vardy 2
Allen 6 Venables 1

From the coach[]

"It would have been a great game to watch. I thought Melbourne just came over and threw everything at us. It looked like a really good game. There were ebbs and flows. We couldn’t stop their ball movement. Their speed and the way that they attack the corridor was something we prepared for but to shut it down was really difficult. We were probably fortunate there at stages with supply against us. That was a concern, but I thought the boys handled it quite well in the end. In the last quarter, it was just a tough, hard slog. I’m really, really proud of our players.

"...I think we’re still a little bit inconsistent. We haven’t quite hit a four-quarter performance, but we’re winning, so that’s the pleasing part. We’re 6-3 and hopefully setting up a really good platform for the second half of the season. But no, we’re not playing at our best. Teams are shutting us down; we’re not helping ourselves as well, but if we’re alive in the contest we can keep getting to work.

"The way we played in the last was around the contest, around winning the ball and getting deeper entries and all those type of things that you want as a coach. The boys have been together for a while, they know some of the things that we can go to if we have to. We’d just like to start a bi better and get a little bit more consistent with our ball movement throughout four quarters. But Melbourne was tough, that was a tough game. I’ve said this before, but winning’s really hard and we’ll take what happened tonight any day of the week."[2]

From the papers[]

The West Australian[]

"The contrasting styles of football made for intriguing viewing.

West Coast’s slow and careful ball movement was up against Melbourne’s high- risks, high-octane style.

The frenetic pressure from both sides resulted in some big bumps and bruises - and a guernsey torn to shreds.

Eagles speedster Jack Petruccelle was running at full pace when he was grabbed by Frost, who ripped his opponent’s jersey clean down the seam."[3]

The Age[]

"Melbourne’s first goal came a lot quicker on Friday night, with Nathan Jones hitting the scoreboard two minutes into the game.

They held on to hold a four-point advantage at half-time and by 12 points at the last break.

But their disposal let them down and they were wasteful in front of goals. They led by 19 points in the third term, but then started to overuse it.

They had 15 more inside 50 entries than the Eagles and four more scoring shots."[4]


Round 6 (16 May)

West Coast suffered a sizeable loss to former reserves affiliate East Perth on a chilly Thursday night. In front of a sparse crowd, the Eagles fought back to narrow the margin to 21 points at the final change but the Royals were able to pull away in the last term to run out 34 point winners. Brayden Ainsworth had a team-high 27 possessions and Matthew Allen had 20 touches and a goal.

1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
East Perth 4.2.26 7.4.46 9.5.59 13.8.86
West Coast 2.3.15 3.3.21 5.8.38 7.10.52

Goals: M.Allen, Brooksby, Cameron, Hug, O'Neill, Smith, Waterman

Best: Ainsworth, Ah Chee, Fisher, Smith, Williams

Injuries: Nil

Named side:

West Coast
B: 51.Fisher 42.Edwards 46.Riach
HB: 35.Rotham 38.Mutimer 52.Acres
C: 30.Nelson 41.Ah Chee 43.M.Allen
HF: 61.Robilliard 32.Williams 29.Foley
F: 66.Reid 36.McInnes 39.Cameron
R: 40.Brooksby 24.O'Neill 33.Ainsworth
I: 11.Grey 16.Hickey 56.Hug
E: 59.Ashman 54.Coe 64.Curnow

In: Mutimer, Cameron, Grey, Hickey, Kalajzic

Out: Brayshaw (toe), Brander, Smith (AFL), Ashman, Curnow

Late changes: Waterman, Smith for Hickey, Nelson

New: Joel Kalajjzic (East Fremantle)

Injury list[]

In the leadup to the match the following players were listed as injured or unavailable:

Player Injury Expected return
Naitanui Knee Indefinite
Barrass Foot 8-10 weeks
Brayshaw Toe 3 weeks
Rioli Foot Test
Cameron Wrist Test
Hickey Hamstring Test
Bines* Hernia TBC
Watson* AC joint 2 weeks



  1. West Coast Eagles Yearbook 2019, p.36
  2. westcoasteagles.com.au (20 May 2019), "Pressing questions": https://www.westcoasteagles.com.au/news/2019-05-20/round-9-pressing-questions
  3. The West Australian (17 May 2019), "Liam Ryan, Willie Rioli inspire West Coast Eagles’ comeback win": https://thewest.com.au/sport/west-coast-eagles/liam-ryan-willie-rioli-inspire-west-coast-eagles-comeback-win-ng-b881203364z
  4. Brad Elborough, The Age (17 May 2019), "West Coast come from behind to punish wayward Demons": https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/west-coast-come-from-behind-to-punish-wayward-demons-20190517-p51omx.html