West Coast Eagles Wiki
Advertisement
West Coast v Melbourne
Round 8, 2025
McGovern was subbed out at half time. Photo: aflphotos.com.au
Date
Sat, 3 May 2025 (5.35pm WST)
Attendance
41,991
Result
Lost by 32
Score
MEL 16.12.108 - 11.10.76 WCE
Brownlow
Ladder
18th
<--Prev
Next-->

West Coast squandered an opportunity to get on the board for 2025, falling to Melbourne at home. Despite being smashed in the midfield, the Eagles hit a purple patch late in the second term and went into halftime a goal ahead, but wilted in the third quarter as Melbourne put on seven goals to continue the home fans' ongoing misery. Elijah Hewett continued his promising form with three goals from 15 touches and co-captain Liam Duggan had 18 possessions and a game-high 577 metres gained.

Summary[]

1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
West Coast 0.5.5 4.7.31 6.7.43 11.10.76
Melbourne 2.2.14 3.7.25 10.12.72 16.12.108

Goals: Hewett, Waterman 3, Cripps 2, Brockman, Hunt, J.Williams

Best: Waterman, Ginbey, Hewett, Allan, Maric, Baker

Injuries: McGovern (concussion), A.Reid (ankle), Ginbey (nose)

Subs: (WCE) Cole for McGovern (concussion) at half-time; (MEL) Sharp for Petty (concussion) at half-time

Milestones: Kelly 150th AFL game, Allen 100th game, Allan AFL debut

Jumper: Home, blue shorts

Named sides[]

West Coast Essendon
B: 23.Maric 20.McGovern 3.Baker B: 17.Bowey 1.May 24.Rivers
HB: 14.Duggan 12.Allen 5.Hunt HB: 4.McVee 25.McDonald 6.Windsor
C: 19.Hough 11.Kelly 26.Allan C: 32.Sparrow 7.Viney 20.Lindsay
HF: 16.Owies 2.Waterman 17.Graham HF: 12.Tholstrup 18.Melksham 15.Langdon
F: 15.Cripps 22.A.Reid 1.Ryan F: 37.Chandler 31.Fritsch 36.Pickett
R: 25.Flynn 44.Hutchinson 9.H.Reid R: 11.Gawn 5.Petracca 19.Langford
I: 7.Ginbey 8.Hewett 10.Brockman I: 3.Salem 9.Spargo 10.Turner
28.Cole 34.J.Williams 30.Sharp 35.Petty
E: 27.Gross 32.B.Williams 38.Davis E: 2.Van Rooyen 16.Laurie 22.Howes

In: Kelly, Allan, Brockman

Out: Dewar, Long, Davis

Quarter by quarter[]

From the coach[]

From the papers[]

The West Australian[]

"West Coast’s midfielders simply didn’t work hard enough for long enough to match Melbourne’s intensity.

Tim Kelly celebrated his 150th game with only 14 disposals, while defender Brady Hough (12 touches) looked out of place in his new role in the middle of the ground.

Eagles coach Andrew McQualter tried to mix it up, sending in Liam Baker, Liam Ryan and Tyler Brockman at various stages, but Gawn’s influence meant any move he made mattered little.

Melbourne were electric in the first term, dominating at the clearances 12-2 and slicing West Coast’s team defence open with precision kicking."[1]

The Age[]

"Demons coach Simon Goodwin was understandably frustrated that his team didn’t have the lead at half-time.

They would have grown after watching Jamie Cripps kick the opening goal of the third quarter.

But with McGovern no longer there to fend off Melbourne’s forays forward, the Demons finally cashed in on their clearance dominance, slamming through six goals for the term to take a 29-point lead into the final change.

Gawn, who had 0.7 to his name for the season up until that point, put the icing on the cake with a set shot goal in the final quarter."[2]

Reserves[]

Round 5 (3 May)

West Coast's reserves won their first game of 2025, knocking off ladder leaders South Fremantle in a massive upset. An Eagles side stacked with AFL-listed players turned the screws on Souths early, holding them goalless until late in the first half as they opened up a commanding lead at half-time. Clay Hall (30 disposals, eight tackles) and Tyrell Dewar (26 disposals, seven marks) were among the young Eagles who put their hand up for a senior recall.

1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
South Fremantle 0.3.3 1.5.11 4.8.32 9.12.66
West Coast 1.3.9 7.5.47 9.8.62 12.10.82

Goals: Champion, Livingstone, Shanahan, B.Williams 2, Datson, Edwards-Baldwin, Petruccelle, Rawlinson

Best: Hall, Brock, B.Williams, Dewar, Davis, Sparks

Injuries: Nil

Named side:

West Coast
B: 33.Bazzo 40.Jamieson 56.Edwards-Baldwin
HB: 51.Sparks 41.Brock 70.Lucassen
C: 43.Dewar 31.Grego 24.Johnston
HF: 37.Champion 21.Petruccelle 13.Long
F: 39.Livingstone 35.Shanahan 30.Barnett
R: 32.B.Williams 29.Hall 27.Gross
I: 50.Datson 38.Davis 61.McCarthy
36.Rawlinson
E: 64.Mercer 55.Sambo 58.Walsh
66.L.Yeo

In: Long, Dewar, Davis, Sparks

Out: Allan (AFL), Edwards (ankle), Mercer, L.Yeo

Injury list[]

In the leadup to the match the following players were listed as injured or unavailable:

Player Injury Expected return
Sheed Knee Season
Yeo Ankle/knee TBC
Chesser Ankle 3-4 weeks
Kelly Toe Available (not on official list)

References[]

https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/7039

  1. Mitchell Woodcock, The West Australian (3 May 2025), "Melbourne skipper Max Gawn tears West Coast to shreds to ensure Eagles still winless in 2025 AFL season": https://thewest.com.au/sport/west-coast-eagles/melbourne-skipper-max-gawn-tears-west-coast-to-shreds-to-ensure-eagles-still-winless-in-2025-afl-season-c-18571019
  2. The Age (3 May 2025), "Gawn stands tall as Demons beat Eagles for third straight win": https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/afl-2025-round-eight-live-western-bulldogs-v-port-adelaide-in-ballarat-launch-super-saturday-action-20250502-p5lw28.html
Advertisement