Carlton v West Coast
Round 20, 2019
Sun, 4 August 2019 (3.20pm EST)
Won by 24
WCE 15.9.99 - 11.9.75 CAR
3 L.Shuey (WCE)
2 S.Walsh (CAR)
1 E.Yeo (WCE)

West Coast had a relatively easy win over Carlton in Melbourne, breaking the game open with a seven-goal second quarter but gave up the chance to boost their percentage after easing off in the final term. Liam Ryan kicked a career-high four goals and Luke Shuey kicked two from his 28 possessions.

Summary[edit | edit source]

1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
Carlton 4.1.25 6.3.39 8.4.54 11.9.75
West Coast 2.5.17 9.5.59 14.7.91 15.9.99

Goals: Ryan 4, Darling, Shuey, Waterman 2, O.Allen, Cameron, Kennedy, Petruccelle, Rioli

Best: Shuey, Yeo, McGovern, Ryan, Gaff, Sheppard, Hickey

Injuries: Nil

Milestones: Yeo 150th AFL game, Nelson 50th game

Named sides[edit | edit source]

West Coast Carlton
B: 25.Hurn 37.Barrass 31.Schofield B: 24.Newman 23.Weitering 39.Thomas
HB: 23.Jetta 20.McGovern 5.Sheppard HB: 5.Petrevski-Seton 20.Plowman 6.Simpson
C: 8.Redden 13.Shuey 4.Sheed C: 4.O'Brien 9.Cripps 43.Setterfield
HF: 21.Petruccelle 27.Darling 44.Rioli HF: 40.Gibbons 41.Casboult 1.J.Silvagni
F: 1.Ryan 17.Kennedy 12.O.Allen F: 16.Lang 10.McKay 7.Kennedy
R: 16.Hickey 6.Yeo 3.Gaff R: 34.Phillips 18.Walsh 35.E.Curnow
I: 2.Waterman 7.Masten 30.Nelson I: 25.Fisher 3.Murphy 47.Deluca
39.Cameron 45.Goddard*
E: 26.Watson 28.Cole 32.Williams E: 32.Fasolo 27.Lobbe 2.Dow
34.Hutchings 19.Schumacher*

In: Hurn

Out: Watson

Late change: (CAR) Schumacher for Thomas (ill)

(*Goddard replaced Jones in 22, Schumacher added to emergencies)

Quarter by quarter[edit | edit source]

Carlton replaced Dale Thomas with debutant Angus Schumacher, while the Eagles went as named. The game was played under the closed Docklands roof.

Club Champion votes[edit | edit source]


McGovern 15 Cameron 5
Ryan 15 Hurn 5
Yeo 15 Petruccelle 5
Shuey 14 Redden 5
Barrass 11 Waterman 5
Gaff 10 Jetta 4
Sheppard 10 Kennedy 4
Darling 9 Masten 3
Nelson 6 Schofield 3
Rioli 6 Sheed 2
Allen 5 Hickey 0

From the coach[edit | edit source]

"It was a good win, yep. Really pleased. We knew what Carlton were all about. (They've won) five out of the last seven games, their brand is pretty obvious, so we’re very happy to get away with the win.

"I thought the contest, around the stoppages, we were really struggling. It was a battle for most of the night. But when we got supply we looked pretty dangerous in the front half. Our tall backs, at stages, had good influence on the game and when we got some supply I thought our high half forwards looked pretty quick tonight. We were pretty efficient in front of goals.

"...We weren’t great today at stoppages, we got touched up. So last week, or the week before, we’ve had good days. We’re scoring from stoppages really well, for me it’s really hard to say let’s just fix this one part because next week it’ll be good. We’re just trying to play total footy I suppose, but that doesn’t happen. So we’ll look at that, it’s one of Carlton’s real strengths. It was probably the biggest issue we had for most of the day – how do we stop the clearance domination and metres from clearances. We had pretty good metres from turnovers, but that might change next week so I won’t over analyse it."[2]

From the papers[edit | edit source]

The West Australian[edit | edit source]

"Carlton battled without three first choice defenders - Liam Jones (bereavement), Dale Thomas (illness), Caleb Marchbank (injury) - as well as long-term absentee Sam Docherty.

They led mid-way through the second quarter after a spell of midfield dominance, led by Sam Walsh on a quiet day for Cripps.

Then, in the blink of an eye, West Coast took the contest away.

Three goals in three minutes saw the Eagles regain the lead and three more in time-on turned a seesawing contest into a comfortable afternoon."[3]

The Age[edit | edit source]

"The brilliance of Sam Walsh (31 possessions) and Nic Newman (24 possessions, four goals) gave the Blues a deserving lead at quarter time with Walsh's ultra-classy pivot turn, left-foot goal a highlight.

But the Eagles kept pressing, pressuring and, when they could, pummelling the young Blues while Ryan pulled in a contender for both best mark and bravest mark of the year running back into the pack for a courageous grab.

The Eagles had a 20-point lead at half time. Moments into the third term the Jake Waterman kicked truly from point-blank range and Ryan kicked his snap goal and another soon after, doubling their 20-point lead and the premiership points looked to be decided.

As good as the Eagles were, the Blues kept pushing their case as small forwards like Michael Gibbons (three goals) and Newman (four goals) cutting the lead to 24 points when it could have blown out further."[4]

Reserves[edit | edit source]

Round 17 (3 August)

West Coast's finals hopes all but evaporated with a loss to bottom-placed Swan Districts at a wet Bassendean Oval. The Eagles, down to two fit men on the bench after losing Liam Duggan and Jarrod Brander to leg injuries, fought back from 26 points down at half-time to take the lead but Swans were able to find one last goal and then lock the contest down. Matthew Allen had a team-high 25 touches and kicked an important last-quarter goal and fellow midfielder Hamish Brayshaw tallied 23 possessions.

1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
Swan Districts 3.1.19 9.5.59 10.7.67 12.8.80
West Coast 3.3.21 5.3.33 8.3.51 12.4.76

Goals: Reid 3, Flint 2, Ah Chee, M.Allen, Brander, Fisher, Hutchings, Mutimer, Vardy

Best: Reid, Ah Chee, M.Allen, Brayshaw, Brander, Watson

Injuries: Duggan (corked thigh), Brander (ankle)

Named side:

West Coast
B: 61.Robilliard 42.Edwards 64.Curnow
HB: 51.Fisher 35.Rotham 14.Duggan
C: 38.Mutimer 41.Ah Chee 33.Ainsworth
HF: 24.O'Neill 36.McInnes 10.Brander
F: 66.Reid 40.Brooksby 59.Ashman
R: 19.Vardy 43.M.Allen 22.Brayshaw
I: 47.Bines 55.Flint 65.Hobbs
E: 52.Acres 58.Busher 53.Kalajzic

In: Duggan, Ainsworth, Edwards, Robilliard, Bines

Out: Cole, Williams (AFL), Foley (calf), Petrie (rested), Cary (hamstring)

Late changes: Hutchings, Watson, Williams for McInnes (quad), Hobbs, Hug

Injury list[edit | edit source]

In the leadup to the match the following players were listed as injured or unavailable:

Player Injury Expected return
Venables Concussion Season
Naitanui Ankle Indefinite
Cripps Abductor 1 week
Duggan Ankle Test
Hutchings Hamstring Test
Hurn Calf Test
Riach* Stress fracture TBC
Smith* Hamstring 4-6 weeks
Edwards* Foot Test

References[edit | edit source]

  1. West Coast Eagles Yearbook 2019, p.46
  2. (6 August 2019), "Round 20: Pressing questions":
  3. AAP & staff writers, The West Australian (4 August 2019), "West Coast Eagles inch to within percentage of top spot with 24-point win over Carlton":
  4. Roy Ward, The Age (4 August 2019), "Eagles tune-up for finals by steamrolling the Blues":
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.