West Coast Eagles Wiki
West Coast v Collingwood
Round 17, 2019
Fri, 12 July 2019 (6.10pm WST)
Lost by 1
COL 11.12.78 - 12.5.77 WCE
3 S.Sidebottom (COL)
2 S.Pendlebury (COL)
1 A.Treloar (COL)

West Coast lost a thriller to Collingwood despite leading at every change, with the Magpies swamping the home side in the last quarter and edging their way in front to record a 1-point win. The match began as a shootout with both sides kicking six goals in the first term, but scoring dried up in the second half, with the panicking Eagles unable to score more than a single point in the final term. Youngster Jarrod Cameron kicked four first-half goals, his second straight four-goal haul, and Elliot Yeo had eight tackles and 26 disposals to go with his two goals, but West Coast lost Jamie Cripps to a nasty groin injury before quarter-time.


1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
West Coast 6.3.39 10.4.64 12.4.76 12.5.77
Collingwood 6.1.37 8.3.51 9.6.60 11.12.78

Goals: Cameron 4, Darling 3, Yeo 2, O.Allen, Hickey, Ryan

Best: Yeo, Gaff, Cameron, Darling, Sheppard, Redden, Jetta

Injuries: Cripps (adductor)

Named sides[]

West Coast Collingwood
B: 25.Hurn 37.Barrass 28.Cole B: 37.Maynard 23.Roughead 19.Greenwood
HB: 5.Sheppard 20.McGovern 23.Jetta HB: 25.Crisp 30.Moore 35.Quaynor
C: 4.Sheed 8.Redden 3.Gaff C: 21.Phillips 10.Pendlebury 16.Mayne
HF: 39.Cameron 27.Darling 15.Cripps HF: 17.C.Brown 46.Cox 32.Hoskin-Elliott
F: 1.Ryan 17.Kennedy 44.Rioli F: 2.De Goey 41.Mihocek 5.Elliott
R: 9.Naitanui 6.Yeo 13.Shuey R: 4.Grundy 7.Treloar 22.Sidebottom
I: 7.Masten 12.O.Allen 16.Hickey I: 14.Aish 49.Noble 36.Sier
30.Nelson 39.Crocker
E: 21.Petruccelle 31.Schofield 43.M.Allen E: 34.T.Brown 24.Thomas 12.Scharenberg
45.Smith 26.Daicos

In: Kennedy, Cole

Out: Ah Chee (calf), Duggan (ankle)

Quarter by quarter[]

Both sides went in as named. The match was played in fine and clear conditions.

Club Champion votes[]


Cameron 13 Barrass 4
Jetta 11 Cole 4
Yeo 11 Naitanui 4
Darling 8 Ryan 4
Sheppard 8 Allen 3
Gaff 6 Sheed 3
Masten 6 McGovern 2
Hurn 5 Rioli 2
Nelson 5 Hickey 1
Redden 5 Cripps 0
Shuey 5 Kennedy 0

From the coach[]

"It would have been a pretty good game to watch. I think there was three or four chapters within that game that ebbed and flowed. The first quarter, both teams kicked six goals, which I don’t know if both teams would have been happy with that. We were getting scored against from clearances, we were probably getting them on turnovers a little bit. We just ran out of steam in the second half really and their ability to sustain effort was better than ours and that’s pretty much what it came down to in the last quarter. We couldn’t win the ball, we couldn’t get any field position and it looked like they just wanted it a little bit more than we did at stages.

"Momentum shifts happen. I thought our defenders early were off and Collingwood’s forwards … had the better of us. But as the game wore on I thought they stepped up to the level we’ve seen before. But for them to lose Moore early made them really small and to lose Cripps for us early made us really tall. So one of those things was going to work in someone’s favour and I thought we just looked a bit out of whack in the front half. But that was sort of secondary to the intensity and effort that Collingwood put in, particularly in the last quarter. We were just holding up the dam wall early.

"... I thought their mids as a collective in the last just won the critical contests and you look at the contested (ball) discrepancy, but sometimes that doesn’t tell the true picture. But tonight I thought the really important plays it could have gone either way and the ball bounces around, we didn’t win any of those and we normally win our fair share."[2]

From the papers[]

The West Australian[]

"The scoring dried up in the third term which suited West Coast who edged a further goal clear. The fit bodies were also drying up for Collingwood who had ruckman Brodie Grundy limping but still out there, Pendlebury out there but nursing a hand injury and James Aish sent to the rooms after landing heavily on his right shoulder.

And the Pies were finding scoring increasingly hard. They were caught between a rock and a hard place. To bridge the 16-point margin they faced at three quarter time they were going to have to open the game up more. And that was going to put them at great risk of being scored against by West Coast’s potent attack.

Darling was still a threat and had kicked one of his team’s two third quarter goals and gifted the other to Yeo. Midfielder Tom Phillips had kicked the only third term major for the Pies.

The last term was sheer mayhem as the Pies chose the hard road over the free scoring one. They surged and surged but couldn’t score. West Coast couldn’t clear the ball from their defensive fifty."[3]

The Age[]

"Both teams kicked six goals in the opening quarter, the first coming from the boot of Jack Darling within a minute of the start. Collingwood hadn’t even touched the ball.

But the Pies got going and traded blows with the reigning premiers. Eagles small forward Jarrod Cameron kicked three goals in seven minutes midway through the term.

Magpie Talls Mason Cox and Brody Mihocek kicked two apiece, both from marks.

The lead changed six times during the first term. Darling’s second goal, kicked just before the siren, left the Eagles with a two-point lead."[4]


Round 14 (14 July)

West Coast celebrated the public opening of their new headquarters at Lathlain Park with a comfortable win over West Perth. The Falcons kiced three quick goals after half-time to close within 11 points but the Eagles shifted to another gear in the last term, kicking eight goals to one to record a 69-point victory. Jake Waterman kicked six goals and Jack Petruccelle had five on his return from injury, and Brayden Ainsworth had 26 possessions in the midfield.

1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
West Perth 2.0.12 5.2.32 9.5.59 10.5.65
West Coast 3.5.23 9.9.63 12.11.83 20.14.134

Goals: Waterman 6, Petruccelle 5, McInnes 3, M.Allen, Ashman, Brander, Brooksby, Flint, Williams

Best: Waterman, Watson, Peytruccelle, Ainsworth, Smith, M.Allen

Injuries: Smith (hamstring)

Reports: Grey for rough conduct against C.West

Named side:

West Coast
B: 46.Riach 9.Petrie 64.Curnow
HB: 26.Watson 35.Rotham 51.Fisher
C: 38.Mutimer 33.Ainsworth 10.Brander
HF: 59.Ashman 36.McInnes 55.Flint
F: 2.Waterman 40.Brooksby 66.Reid
R: 32.Williams 22.Brayshaw 11.Grey
I 43.M.Allen 21.Petruccelle 31.Schofield
E: 56.Hug 58.Busher 62.Cary

In: Brander, Petruccelle, Schofield

Out: Foley (soreness), Robilliard, Cary

Injury list[]

In the leadup to the match the following players were listed as injured or unavailable:

Player Injury Expected return
Venables Concussion TBC
Duggan Ankle 5-6 weeks
Vardy Knee/ankle 3 weeks
Hutchings Hamstring 2 weeks
Kennedy Illness Test
Petruccelle Hamstring Test
Brander Calf Test
Bines* Hernia 2-3 weeks
Edwards* Foot 2-3 weeks



  1. West Coast Eagles Yearbook 2019, p.43
  2. westcoasteagles.com.au (15 July 2019), "Round 17: Pressing questions": https://www.westcoasteagles.com.au/news/2019-07-15/round-17-pressing-questions
  3. Mark Duffield, The West Australian (12 July 2019), "West Coast Eagles drop one-point thriller to Collingwood at Optus Stadium": https://thewest.com.au/sport/west-coast-eagles/west-coast-eagles-drop-one-point-thriller-to-collingwood-at-optus-stadium-ng-b881258786z
  4. Brad Elborough, The Age (12 July 2019), "Magnificent Magpies rock Eagles on the road": https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/magnificent-magpies-rock-eagles-on-the-road-20190712-p526tl.html